Critical annotations, environmental history, decolonization, wilderness, environmental health, Chernobyl, global warming, climate change, air pollution, activism, deep ecology
This exercise is a critical annotation of each of the following texts:
- Davis (2007) The Granary of Rome. Ch. 1 and 6
- Merchant (2003) Shades of Darkness: Race and Environmental History
- Nash (2006) Inescapable Ecologies. Ch. 4
- Brown (2019) Chernobyl. An environmental History of the Chernobyl Disaster. Part 3
- Oreskes (2004) Science and public policy: What's proof got to do with it? Environmental Science & Policy 7 (5): 369-383.
- Oreskes, N. et al. (2018) Merchants of Doubt (ch. 6)
- Wilson (2009) The Spiritual History of Ice. Ch. 2
- Carey (2007) "The History of Ice: How Glaciers Became Endangered Species"
- Chakrabarty, D. (2009) The climate of History: Four Theses
- Simon Avenell, "From Fearsome Pollution to Fukushima: Environmental Activism and the Nuclear Blind Spot in Contemporary Japan," Environmental History vol.17 (no.2, 2012): 244-276.
- Ramachandra Guha, Radical American Environmentalism and Wilderness Preservation: A Third World Critique. Environmental Ethics 11 (1989): 71-83.
[...] These initiatives stem from American environmental history, hence not quite fitting the complex realities in less affluent nations. He showcases through Indian scenarios that enforcing U.S.-styled environmental conservation could deepen societal divisions and ignore vital connections between indigenous peoples and their habitats. 1. How can the foundational beliefs of these environmental movements be revised to more actively participate in social justice and economic progression matters 2. What might be the implications of sidelining traditional and regional ecological insights for Western-dominant environmental tactics? [...]
[...] How does Nash explore the differing effects of ecological shifts on various groups? 2. What do Nash's conclusions suggest for the direction of current environmental Nash's publication is distinguished by its exhaustive historical scrutiny, offering a valuable backdrop for grasping today's ecological dilemmas. Yet, the analysis could gain from a clearer elucidation of the research methodologies employed to investigate historical correlations between the environment and disease. Enhancing the argument with a wider array of cross-disciplinary insights, especially those from non-Western traditions, could enrich the narrative with diverse perspectives on environmental health stories. [...]
[...] Is it possible for historical examination to enhance the dialogue on climate policy beyond simply recognizing human influence? The persuasiveness of Chakrabarty's argument stems from its innovative reimagining of historical study in light of climate change, thus broadening the field of historiography. Nevertheless, his propositions might be viewed as overly theoretical, lacking a defined strategy for incorporating this revamped historical viewpoint into actionable climate strategies. Section 7 - Simon Avenell The study delves into Japan's historical interactions with pollution and environmental activism, with a focus on the era spanning the 1960s through the Fukushima incident. [...]
[...] Ch. 2 - Carey (2007) "The History of Ice: How Glaciers Became Endangered Species" - Chakrabarty, D. (2009) The climate of History: Four Theses - Simon Avenell, "From Fearsome Pollution to Fukushima: Environmental Activism and the Nuclear Blind Spot in Contemporary Japan," Environmental History vol.17 (no.2, 2012): 244-276. - Ramachandra Guha, Radical American Environmentalism and Wilderness Preservation: A Third World Critique. Environmental Ethics 11 (1989): 71-83. [...]
[...] have historically sidelined the viewpoints of African American and Native American communities. The article analyzes the ways in which conservation areas have been imbued with racial biases, creating an environmental discourse that frequently omits people of color. 1. In what ways does Merchant's examination confront conventional environmental stories that tend to ignore the roles and experiences of people of color? 2. What are the consequences of the racialization of environmental areas on the modern environmental justice movements? Merchant's analysis is notable for its cross-disciplinary method, blending historical facts, literary critique, and environmental philosophy. [...]
APA Style reference
For your bibliographyOnline reading
with our online readerContent validated
by our reading committee